Sorry, We're Closed

Tuesday, May 31, 2005

LaTroy Story

I've been asked to provide a bit of analysis on the Cubs' recent trade of righthanded reliever LaTroy Hawkins. Chicago sent the 32-year-old Hawkins to the San Francisco Giants on Saturday in exchange for two 23-year-old righthanded pitchers, Jerome Williams and David Aardsma.

The Cubs had to pick up nearly all of Hawkins' 2005 salary of $4.35 million; the Giants will pay Hawkins that same amount if Hawkins exercises his player option for 2006. Since coming to Chicago in 2004, Hawkins has been a setup man, closer, and, recently, a mopup reliever.

Jerome Williams, a 39th-round draft pick in 1999, fashioned a 10-7 mark last year for the Giants; in his 43 major league games, all starts, he is an impressive 17-12 with a 3.77 ERA. This spring, he didn't have much time to pitch; he spent much of March with his ailing father, then started the season at Triple-A. The Cubs have sent Williams to their Triple-A club in Iowa, but would like him to be in the majors soon.

Aardsma, a first-round pick in 2003, was a star relief pitcher at Rice University and pitched in 11 games last year for San Francisco. The Giants sent him to Double-A this spring and converted him to starting, where he was 6-2 before the deal. It's not clear, even to the Cubs, whether Aardsma is going to be a starter, middleman, setup man, or closer.

Those are the facts. But what do they all mean?

My opinion is that Hawkins got a raw deal. Most every closer in baseball goes through rough stretches. While every team would love to have the 2004 version of Eric Gagne, the facts are that most pitchers, even the good closers, just aren't that dominating. Much was made of Hawkins' lousy record in one-run games; in fact, his career record in those situations is 18-for-24. That's 75 percent, and that's well within the realm of "acceptable to good." (And if the Cubs had a better offense, they wouldn't be worried about protecting so many damn one-run leads.)

Hawkins' failures came in short stretches and at memorable times. Had he not gotten off this season on the wrong foot, Chicago would have almost certainly lived with him; it's much easier to justify a mid-season slump than one in April. Watch what happens when Ryan Dempster sags this summer, or Dustin Hermanson on the South Side soon reverts to being, well, Dustin Hermanson.

Remember that Hawkins never campaigned for the closer's role. He never WANTED the job, and only took it because his manager asked him to. It's not Hawkins' fault that Jim Hendry whole-heartedly embraces the strategy of bottom-feeding for bench players and relief pitchers. Cub "fans" who took LaTroy Hawkins' struggles personally, booing him, cursing him, for God's sake, because he blew a few one-run leads, ought to look in the mirror. He tried as hard as he could, and it didn't work out.

Jerome Williams has four pitches: sinker, slider, curve, and change. His sinker has just slightly above average velocity, but moves well and induces ground balls. Williams' best pitch is his change-up; he has a good late break on his slider. He is prized for his intelligence, reluctance to give up walks, and ability to use patterns to keep hitters off balance. Scouts project him, conservatively, as a solid #4 starter. I think he could be better than that, assuming that he gets into game condition and that his cranky elbow stays healthy (this is a fairly big if, but Williams has not been overused so far in his career). He pitched well Tuesday night in his first Triple-A Cubs appearance.

David Aardsma is a very hard thrower, utilizing mostly sinkers and sliders. He is developing a change-up in order to expand his usability (unless they're knuckleballers, starters just don't survive without at least three pitches). While he was effective in college, Aardsma, as a late-inning reliever, just didn't pitch that much. As a result, he rarely experienced failure, and needs time in the minors to adjust to the inevitable struggles that will follow as hitters learn him and force him to make adjustments.

On an analytical basis, I love the trade. Bringing in young arms is a great strategy for a club that can't seem to keep its major-league pitchers off the disabled list. Trading a 32-year-old that you have no intention of using in a critical role for two 23-year-olds with reasonably high ceilings is also excellent strategy.

But emotionally, I'm not crazy about getting rid of Hawkins. Believe it or not, I'll miss him; he wasn't very good at mouthing the usual platitudes that sportswriters love, and that trait endeared him to me. Hawkins was respected by his teammates and pitched effectively when used correctly.

And in the end, he's just a scapegoat, really, of 1)a starting rotation that hasn't done the job, forcing overuse of the bullpen, 2)an offense that hasn't provided nearly enough runs, and 3)a manager and GM who haven't clearly formulated or communicated their plan to make this franchise as good on the field as it is on the bottom line.


Anonymous emcee said...

I appreciate players who don't deal in cliches and platitudes, but Hawkins seemed allergic to the notion of letting fans think he cared about them. And he started his career as a closer on such an off note--with that pre-emptive, hostile press conference he called to say he won't be talking to reporters about the saves he might blow--that it was hard to feel for the guy when he gave up leads in crucial games. Not saying the booers are justified--the growing sense of entitlement at Wrigley is fouling the vibe--but it's more fun to root for people if you like them and you think they like you back.

8:22 AM, June 01, 2005

Anonymous JFG said...

I agree, the sense of entitlement and anger around the ballpark stinks. Maybe it's an inevitable fallout from 2003, and will only be wiped out by a world series appearance.

Why can't these players have more fun? Think back to any team that has a place in your heart--that team will have a fair share of characters, goofs, friendly guys, etc. Seems like the only personable guy on the team is Aramis Ramirez (at least, if you ain't dressed like a wiener).

9:56 AM, June 01, 2005

Blogger Kevin Hennessy said...

A brief history from Latroy's Minnesota chapter:

1) He bombed as a starter, and was given more than enough chances to succeed. At one time I was working on a "Brock-like" system to project pitchers. I'm sure it would have retired Hawkins long before the Twins tried him out as a reliever.

2) When the Twins did use him in relief in 2000 (after being used exclusively as a starter from 1995-1999, with only one relief appearance), he was almost immediately thrust into taking on a closer role (due to lack of candidates, perhaps?). In 2000 he was 14-14 in save opportunities (his first save coming May 28) and stretched that to 23 straight before blowing one in 2001. In the end he saved 28 and blew 9 in 2001, and was not the closer at the end of the season, with Eddie Guardado being tried in that role (which he took over). I'm sure there was some heat from the press, but the manager was Tom Kelly and Hawkins walked a few people. Kelly prefered pitchers who threw strikes, even if they ended up flying over the fence. The press probably would be a welcome distraction to Kelly's critiques in the end.

3) So Hawkins became a great setup man in 2002. Much credit was given to Rick Anderson, the new pitching coach under Ron Gardenhire. He was for the most part invincible as a setup man, with the only meltdown I ever remember being vs. the Yankees in the 2003 playoffs. His control during his time as a setup man was very good.

4) The Cubs signed him and his career as a Twins came to a close.

To sum up:
Failed as a starter.
Started well as a closer but floundered in the end.
Excelled as a setup man with a new pitching coach.

Kevin Hennessy

4:59 AM, June 18, 2005

Anonymous 0 apr business card credit said...

I just came across your blog about 1 business hosting small web and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.

If you have a moment, please visit my site:
1 business hosting small web
It also covers 1 business hosting small web related stuff.
I send you warm regards and wish you continued success.

8:37 AM, November 06, 2005

Anonymous average salary youth leader said...

Your blog I found to be very interesting!
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
I have a average salary youth leader
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Best regards!

10:29 AM, July 15, 2006


Post a Comment

<< Home